This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendants of slaves.
POV documentaries can be recorded off-the-air and used for educational purposes for up to one year from the initial broadcast. In addition, POV offers a lending library of DVDs that you can borrow anytime during the school year — FOR FREE! Please visit our Film Library to find other films suitable for classroom use or to make this film a part of your school's permanent collection.
OBJECTIVES
By the end of this lesson, students will:
Use viewing skills and note-taking strategies to understand and interpret video clips.
Label a map to indicate the locations and commodities used in the slave trade.
Discuss the role the North played in U.S. slavery.
Develop and defend a written position on the idea of reparations for the descendants of slaves in the U.S.
GRADE LEVELS: 6-12
SUBJECTS: U.S. History, Economics, Geography, Civics, Current Events
MATERIALS NEEDED
Method (varies by school) of showing the class online video clips
Computers with access to the Internet
Map handouts showing Rhode Island, Cuba, and the west coast of Africa. You can easily make and print a map at National Geographic's MapMachine.
ESTIMATED TIME OF COMPLETION: One 50-minute class
SUGGESTED CLIPS
Clip 1: Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery (length: 4:57)
The clip begins at 27:55, just after, "At the forts we met with... The clip ends with a shot of the "door of no return at 32:52.
Clip 2: Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation (length 4:08)
The clip begins at 67:18, just after, "At this point, I decided we should dive directly into the questions of reparations.... The clip ends at 71:26, just after, "...want to do something about it.
BACKGROUND
Katrina Browne, who directed the documentary, Traces of the Trade, is a descendant of the DeWolf family of Bristol, Rhode Island. Generations of the family include a U.S. senator, state legislators, philanthropists, writers, professors, and Episcopal priests and bishops. In colonial times, the family was one of the wealthiest on the continent. Their entrepreneurship virtually built Bristol's economy: many of the buildings they funded still stand, and the stained glass windows at St. Michael's Episcopal Church bear DeWolf names to this day.
The DeWolf family fortune was based on buying and selling human beings. For over fifty years and three generations, from 1769 to 1820, the DeWolfs were America's leading slave traders. In Traces of the Trade, Browne and other family members follow the path of the Triangle Trade as they seek to better understand this dark period of their family history. The film points out that U.S. slavery was not just a Southern industry; the North was an active participant as well. It also raises important questions related to modern-day race relations: Do descendants of slave traders have a special obligation to accept responsibility for the "living consequences of their ancestors' crimes? What can or should they do to make amends, if anything? As a nation, how do we deal with what we have all inherited from our country's history?
ACTIVITY
Ask students what they know about slavery in the United States. List responses on the board. Explain to students that while slavery in the United States is more commonly associated with southern states, the North was also actively involved.
Give each student a map handout. Have them label Rhode Island, Cuba, and the modern-day location of Ghana on Africa's west coast.
Tell students that you are going to show them two clips from a documentary made by a woman whose ancestors, the DeWolfs, were the largest slave traders in U.S. history. She and some members of her family traveled to each of these locations on the map to better understand this part of their family's past. When they visited Rhode Island, they spoke with historians and looked at family records to learn how their ancestors carried out the trade. Here is basically how it worked:
Have students draw a line from Rhode Island to Ghana to Cuba and back to Rhode Island to form a triangle. Explain that ships in Rhode Island were loaded with products like rum, which they traded in Africa for slaves. Africans were then shipped to Cuba to work on plantations or to be sold on the open market. Molasses, derived from sugar cane produced with slave labor on plantations in Cuba, was then shipped to Rhode Island to be used to make rum. Have students label their maps with what was shipped to each port (e.g., rum from Rhode Island to Africa). Tell the class that this trading pattern is referred to as the "triangle trade.
Point out that while the DeWolfs and others such as the Brown brothers were directly involved with the slave trade, others in North also supported slavery, for example, distilling rum with molasses produced on plantations with slave labor. Businesses like ship builders, insurance companies, blacksmiths, and others benefited from the slave trade by doing business with those whose wealth was generated by slavery. The practice of slavery was not just a system in place in southern states, it was the foundation of the U.S. economy at that time.
Next, explain that when the family shown in the video went to Ghana on the west coast of Africa, they visited a place where captured Africans were brought and held before being sold as slaves. Then, show students the Suggested Clip, "Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery. As students watch, ask them to imagine what it must have been like for the people brought to that place to become slaves.
Allow students to react to what they saw in the clip. Tell the class that the DeWolf family alone owned 47 ships and brought 10,000 slaves from Africa to the New World. Today, there may be as many as half a million descendants of these people.
Ask the class to think about this question: Do the descendants of those who benefited from slavery need to help repair the injustices and inequality that resulted from slavery? Then, show students Clip 2, "Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation. Focus student viewing by having them take notes on some of the proposals for making repairs shown in the video (e.g., formal apologies, engaging in dialogue, litigation, financial compensation to descendants of slaves, investment in communities). Discuss whether or not students think it is fair for the descendants of slave traders and owners to be held accountable for the actions of their ancestors.
Have students, possibly for homework, read additional information on the POV website about the debate surrounding reparations legislation around the country. Each student should then write a position paper that states and defends his or her viewpoint on the concept of reparations.
ASSESSMENT
Students can be assessed on:
Labeling their maps completely and accurately.
Participation in class discussion.
Quality of position paper, including grammar,
organization, use of arguments, etc.
EXTENSIONS & ADAPTATIONS
Read the excerpt on the POV website
from the book, Inheriting the Trade by Thomas Norman DeWolf, one of the family members in the film. Ask students what the legacy of slavery is in the United States. Have each student bring in a news article or an object that symbolizes this legacy in their minds. Break into groups for show and tell and then have a reporter from each group summarize what was discussed. Ask students whether or not white privilege still exists in the U.S. and have them defend their responses. As part of this discussion, you may also wish to read and analyze the article, "White Privilege: Swimming in Racial Preference."
Watch the film, Traces of the Trade in its entirety. How do the emotions and overall perspectives of family members change during the course of their journey? Imagine you are a member of the group and write a journal entry after visiting each place in the film.
Delve deeper into race issues with other POV films. Two Towns of Jasper documents a town's reaction to a black man's murder at the hand of white supremacists. A related lesson plan examines white privilege. Another film, Family Name, tells about a white man's search for the slaves and slave owners who lived on the plantations once owned by his family. Use it to kick-off an essay assignment about how your students' ideas about race have evolved over time.
Learn about the horrors of slaves packed aboard ships by reading the account, "Aboard a Slave Ship, 1829." See also the information and images at Africans in America. Ask students why they think Africans were transported in this way. Discuss who was dehumanized in these circumstances. Blacks? Whites? Both?
Debate whether or not businesses in the North who indirectly profited from slavery (e.g., textile mills that used cotton produced by slave labor, tradesmen who did business with slave traders, towns in which major buildings and infrastructure are built with profits from the slave trade) are just as responsible for slavery as those who engaged in the practice directly.
Have students conduct research to learn more about their family history. Review the difference between "primary and "secondary sources of information, and talk about the types of documents or artifacts that can give clues about one's ancestors. Encourage students to tap whatever research may already exist in their families and then expand it. A free source of online genealogy records, including those for African-American families, is available at familysearch.org Students can then organize their family histories into presentations or displays and share them with the class. Have students also describe what was happening in U.S. and world history at the time one or two of their ancestors were alive.
Research modern-day slavery, including how and where it takes place, who the perpetrators and victims are, and what is being done to stop it. Ask students to identify how they could help abolish the practice and invite them to participate in the effort.
RESOURCES
Religion
This feature gives a summary of arguments both for and against slave reparations.
Slave North
This website provides a state-by-state overview of slavery in the North.
Standard 4: Understands conflict,
cooperation, and interdependence among individuals, groups, and institutions.
Civics
Standard 13: Understands the character of American political and social conflict and
factors that tend to prevent or lower its intensity.
Economics
Standard 2: Understands characteristics of different economic systems, economic
institutions, and economic incentives.
Geography
Standard 11: Understands the patterns and networks of interdependence on Earth's
surface.
Language Arts
Standard 9: Uses viewing skills and
strategies to understand and interpret visual media.
U.S. History
Standard 3: Understands why the Americas attracted Europeans, why they brought enslaved
Africans to their colonies, and how Europeans struggled for control of North
America and the Carribean.
Standard 5: Understands how the values and institutions of European economic life took root in the colonies and how slavery reshaped European and African life in the Americas.
Standard
31: Understands economic, social, and cultural developments in the contemporary United States.
ABOUT THE AUTHORCari Ladd, M.Ed., is an educational writer with a background in broadcast journalism, secondary education and media development. Previously, she served as PBS Interactive's Director of Education, overseeing the development of curricular resources tied to PBS programs, the PBS TeacherSource website (now PBS Teachers), and online teacher professional development services. She has also taught in Maryland and Northern Virginia.
Background Sources:
Jay
Coughtry, The Notorious Triangle: Rhode
Island and the African Slave Trade, 1700-1807 (Philadelphia: Temple Press,
1981);
David Eltis,
Stephen D. Behrendt, David Richardson, and Herbert S. Klein, eds., The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade: A Database
on CD-ROM (Cambridge, 1999);
George Howe, Mount Hope: A New England Chronicle (New York: Viking Press, 1959);
M.A. DeWolfe
Howe, Bristol, Rhode Island: A Town Biography (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1930).
"
["post_title"]=>
string(101) "Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North: Lesson Plan: The History and Legacy of U.S. Slavery"
["post_excerpt"]=>
string(399) "This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendents of slaves."
["post_status"]=>
string(7) "publish"
["comment_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["ping_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["post_password"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_name"]=>
string(11) "lesson-plan"
["to_ping"]=>
string(0) ""
["pinged"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_modified"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 11:22:47"
["post_modified_gmt"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 15:22:47"
["post_content_filtered"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_parent"]=>
int(0)
["guid"]=>
string(56) "http://www.pbs.org/pov/index.php/2008/06/24/lesson-plan/"
["menu_order"]=>
int(0)
["post_type"]=>
string(4) "post"
["post_mime_type"]=>
string(0) ""
["comment_count"]=>
string(1) "0"
["filter"]=>
string(3) "raw"
}
["queried_object_id"]=>
int(3137)
["request"]=>
string(481) "SELECT wp_posts.* FROM wp_posts JOIN wp_term_relationships ON wp_posts.ID = wp_term_relationships.object_id JOIN wp_term_taxonomy ON wp_term_relationships.term_taxonomy_id = wp_term_taxonomy.term_taxonomy_id AND wp_term_taxonomy.taxonomy = 'pov_film' JOIN wp_terms ON wp_term_taxonomy.term_id = wp_terms.term_id WHERE 1=1 AND wp_posts.post_name = 'lesson-plan' AND wp_posts.post_type = 'post'
AND wp_terms.slug = 'tracesofthetrade'
ORDER BY wp_posts.post_date DESC "
["posts"]=>
&array(1) {
[0]=>
object(WP_Post)#7138 (24) {
["ID"]=>
int(3137)
["post_author"]=>
string(1) "1"
["post_date"]=>
string(19) "2008-01-02 16:35:28"
["post_date_gmt"]=>
string(19) "2008-01-02 21:35:28"
["post_content"]=>
string(16440) "
This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendants of slaves.
POV documentaries can be recorded off-the-air and used for educational purposes for up to one year from the initial broadcast. In addition, POV offers a lending library of DVDs that you can borrow anytime during the school year — FOR FREE! Please visit our Film Library to find other films suitable for classroom use or to make this film a part of your school's permanent collection.
OBJECTIVES
By the end of this lesson, students will:
Use viewing skills and note-taking strategies to understand and interpret video clips.
Label a map to indicate the locations and commodities used in the slave trade.
Discuss the role the North played in U.S. slavery.
Develop and defend a written position on the idea of reparations for the descendants of slaves in the U.S.
GRADE LEVELS: 6-12
SUBJECTS: U.S. History, Economics, Geography, Civics, Current Events
MATERIALS NEEDED
Method (varies by school) of showing the class online video clips
Computers with access to the Internet
Map handouts showing Rhode Island, Cuba, and the west coast of Africa. You can easily make and print a map at National Geographic's MapMachine.
ESTIMATED TIME OF COMPLETION: One 50-minute class
SUGGESTED CLIPS
Clip 1: Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery (length: 4:57)
The clip begins at 27:55, just after, "At the forts we met with... The clip ends with a shot of the "door of no return at 32:52.
Clip 2: Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation (length 4:08)
The clip begins at 67:18, just after, "At this point, I decided we should dive directly into the questions of reparations.... The clip ends at 71:26, just after, "...want to do something about it.
BACKGROUND
Katrina Browne, who directed the documentary, Traces of the Trade, is a descendant of the DeWolf family of Bristol, Rhode Island. Generations of the family include a U.S. senator, state legislators, philanthropists, writers, professors, and Episcopal priests and bishops. In colonial times, the family was one of the wealthiest on the continent. Their entrepreneurship virtually built Bristol's economy: many of the buildings they funded still stand, and the stained glass windows at St. Michael's Episcopal Church bear DeWolf names to this day.
The DeWolf family fortune was based on buying and selling human beings. For over fifty years and three generations, from 1769 to 1820, the DeWolfs were America's leading slave traders. In Traces of the Trade, Browne and other family members follow the path of the Triangle Trade as they seek to better understand this dark period of their family history. The film points out that U.S. slavery was not just a Southern industry; the North was an active participant as well. It also raises important questions related to modern-day race relations: Do descendants of slave traders have a special obligation to accept responsibility for the "living consequences of their ancestors' crimes? What can or should they do to make amends, if anything? As a nation, how do we deal with what we have all inherited from our country's history?
ACTIVITY
Ask students what they know about slavery in the United States. List responses on the board. Explain to students that while slavery in the United States is more commonly associated with southern states, the North was also actively involved.
Give each student a map handout. Have them label Rhode Island, Cuba, and the modern-day location of Ghana on Africa's west coast.
Tell students that you are going to show them two clips from a documentary made by a woman whose ancestors, the DeWolfs, were the largest slave traders in U.S. history. She and some members of her family traveled to each of these locations on the map to better understand this part of their family's past. When they visited Rhode Island, they spoke with historians and looked at family records to learn how their ancestors carried out the trade. Here is basically how it worked:
Have students draw a line from Rhode Island to Ghana to Cuba and back to Rhode Island to form a triangle. Explain that ships in Rhode Island were loaded with products like rum, which they traded in Africa for slaves. Africans were then shipped to Cuba to work on plantations or to be sold on the open market. Molasses, derived from sugar cane produced with slave labor on plantations in Cuba, was then shipped to Rhode Island to be used to make rum. Have students label their maps with what was shipped to each port (e.g., rum from Rhode Island to Africa). Tell the class that this trading pattern is referred to as the "triangle trade.
Point out that while the DeWolfs and others such as the Brown brothers were directly involved with the slave trade, others in North also supported slavery, for example, distilling rum with molasses produced on plantations with slave labor. Businesses like ship builders, insurance companies, blacksmiths, and others benefited from the slave trade by doing business with those whose wealth was generated by slavery. The practice of slavery was not just a system in place in southern states, it was the foundation of the U.S. economy at that time.
Next, explain that when the family shown in the video went to Ghana on the west coast of Africa, they visited a place where captured Africans were brought and held before being sold as slaves. Then, show students the Suggested Clip, "Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery. As students watch, ask them to imagine what it must have been like for the people brought to that place to become slaves.
Allow students to react to what they saw in the clip. Tell the class that the DeWolf family alone owned 47 ships and brought 10,000 slaves from Africa to the New World. Today, there may be as many as half a million descendants of these people.
Ask the class to think about this question: Do the descendants of those who benefited from slavery need to help repair the injustices and inequality that resulted from slavery? Then, show students Clip 2, "Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation. Focus student viewing by having them take notes on some of the proposals for making repairs shown in the video (e.g., formal apologies, engaging in dialogue, litigation, financial compensation to descendants of slaves, investment in communities). Discuss whether or not students think it is fair for the descendants of slave traders and owners to be held accountable for the actions of their ancestors.
Have students, possibly for homework, read additional information on the POV website about the debate surrounding reparations legislation around the country. Each student should then write a position paper that states and defends his or her viewpoint on the concept of reparations.
ASSESSMENT
Students can be assessed on:
Labeling their maps completely and accurately.
Participation in class discussion.
Quality of position paper, including grammar,
organization, use of arguments, etc.
EXTENSIONS & ADAPTATIONS
Read the excerpt on the POV website
from the book, Inheriting the Trade by Thomas Norman DeWolf, one of the family members in the film. Ask students what the legacy of slavery is in the United States. Have each student bring in a news article or an object that symbolizes this legacy in their minds. Break into groups for show and tell and then have a reporter from each group summarize what was discussed. Ask students whether or not white privilege still exists in the U.S. and have them defend their responses. As part of this discussion, you may also wish to read and analyze the article, "White Privilege: Swimming in Racial Preference."
Watch the film, Traces of the Trade in its entirety. How do the emotions and overall perspectives of family members change during the course of their journey? Imagine you are a member of the group and write a journal entry after visiting each place in the film.
Delve deeper into race issues with other POV films. Two Towns of Jasper documents a town's reaction to a black man's murder at the hand of white supremacists. A related lesson plan examines white privilege. Another film, Family Name, tells about a white man's search for the slaves and slave owners who lived on the plantations once owned by his family. Use it to kick-off an essay assignment about how your students' ideas about race have evolved over time.
Learn about the horrors of slaves packed aboard ships by reading the account, "Aboard a Slave Ship, 1829." See also the information and images at Africans in America. Ask students why they think Africans were transported in this way. Discuss who was dehumanized in these circumstances. Blacks? Whites? Both?
Debate whether or not businesses in the North who indirectly profited from slavery (e.g., textile mills that used cotton produced by slave labor, tradesmen who did business with slave traders, towns in which major buildings and infrastructure are built with profits from the slave trade) are just as responsible for slavery as those who engaged in the practice directly.
Have students conduct research to learn more about their family history. Review the difference between "primary and "secondary sources of information, and talk about the types of documents or artifacts that can give clues about one's ancestors. Encourage students to tap whatever research may already exist in their families and then expand it. A free source of online genealogy records, including those for African-American families, is available at familysearch.org Students can then organize their family histories into presentations or displays and share them with the class. Have students also describe what was happening in U.S. and world history at the time one or two of their ancestors were alive.
Research modern-day slavery, including how and where it takes place, who the perpetrators and victims are, and what is being done to stop it. Ask students to identify how they could help abolish the practice and invite them to participate in the effort.
RESOURCES
Religion
This feature gives a summary of arguments both for and against slave reparations.
Slave North
This website provides a state-by-state overview of slavery in the North.
Standard 4: Understands conflict,
cooperation, and interdependence among individuals, groups, and institutions.
Civics
Standard 13: Understands the character of American political and social conflict and
factors that tend to prevent or lower its intensity.
Economics
Standard 2: Understands characteristics of different economic systems, economic
institutions, and economic incentives.
Geography
Standard 11: Understands the patterns and networks of interdependence on Earth's
surface.
Language Arts
Standard 9: Uses viewing skills and
strategies to understand and interpret visual media.
U.S. History
Standard 3: Understands why the Americas attracted Europeans, why they brought enslaved
Africans to their colonies, and how Europeans struggled for control of North
America and the Carribean.
Standard 5: Understands how the values and institutions of European economic life took root in the colonies and how slavery reshaped European and African life in the Americas.
Standard
31: Understands economic, social, and cultural developments in the contemporary United States.
ABOUT THE AUTHORCari Ladd, M.Ed., is an educational writer with a background in broadcast journalism, secondary education and media development. Previously, she served as PBS Interactive's Director of Education, overseeing the development of curricular resources tied to PBS programs, the PBS TeacherSource website (now PBS Teachers), and online teacher professional development services. She has also taught in Maryland and Northern Virginia.
Background Sources:
Jay
Coughtry, The Notorious Triangle: Rhode
Island and the African Slave Trade, 1700-1807 (Philadelphia: Temple Press,
1981);
David Eltis,
Stephen D. Behrendt, David Richardson, and Herbert S. Klein, eds., The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade: A Database
on CD-ROM (Cambridge, 1999);
George Howe, Mount Hope: A New England Chronicle (New York: Viking Press, 1959);
M.A. DeWolfe
Howe, Bristol, Rhode Island: A Town Biography (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1930).
"
["post_title"]=>
string(101) "Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North: Lesson Plan: The History and Legacy of U.S. Slavery"
["post_excerpt"]=>
string(399) "This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendents of slaves."
["post_status"]=>
string(7) "publish"
["comment_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["ping_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["post_password"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_name"]=>
string(11) "lesson-plan"
["to_ping"]=>
string(0) ""
["pinged"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_modified"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 11:22:47"
["post_modified_gmt"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 15:22:47"
["post_content_filtered"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_parent"]=>
int(0)
["guid"]=>
string(56) "http://www.pbs.org/pov/index.php/2008/06/24/lesson-plan/"
["menu_order"]=>
int(0)
["post_type"]=>
string(4) "post"
["post_mime_type"]=>
string(0) ""
["comment_count"]=>
string(1) "0"
["filter"]=>
string(3) "raw"
}
}
["post_count"]=>
int(1)
["current_post"]=>
int(-1)
["in_the_loop"]=>
bool(false)
["post"]=>
object(WP_Post)#7138 (24) {
["ID"]=>
int(3137)
["post_author"]=>
string(1) "1"
["post_date"]=>
string(19) "2008-01-02 16:35:28"
["post_date_gmt"]=>
string(19) "2008-01-02 21:35:28"
["post_content"]=>
string(16440) "
This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendants of slaves.
POV documentaries can be recorded off-the-air and used for educational purposes for up to one year from the initial broadcast. In addition, POV offers a lending library of DVDs that you can borrow anytime during the school year — FOR FREE! Please visit our Film Library to find other films suitable for classroom use or to make this film a part of your school's permanent collection.
OBJECTIVES
By the end of this lesson, students will:
Use viewing skills and note-taking strategies to understand and interpret video clips.
Label a map to indicate the locations and commodities used in the slave trade.
Discuss the role the North played in U.S. slavery.
Develop and defend a written position on the idea of reparations for the descendants of slaves in the U.S.
GRADE LEVELS: 6-12
SUBJECTS: U.S. History, Economics, Geography, Civics, Current Events
MATERIALS NEEDED
Method (varies by school) of showing the class online video clips
Computers with access to the Internet
Map handouts showing Rhode Island, Cuba, and the west coast of Africa. You can easily make and print a map at National Geographic's MapMachine.
ESTIMATED TIME OF COMPLETION: One 50-minute class
SUGGESTED CLIPS
Clip 1: Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery (length: 4:57)
The clip begins at 27:55, just after, "At the forts we met with... The clip ends with a shot of the "door of no return at 32:52.
Clip 2: Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation (length 4:08)
The clip begins at 67:18, just after, "At this point, I decided we should dive directly into the questions of reparations.... The clip ends at 71:26, just after, "...want to do something about it.
BACKGROUND
Katrina Browne, who directed the documentary, Traces of the Trade, is a descendant of the DeWolf family of Bristol, Rhode Island. Generations of the family include a U.S. senator, state legislators, philanthropists, writers, professors, and Episcopal priests and bishops. In colonial times, the family was one of the wealthiest on the continent. Their entrepreneurship virtually built Bristol's economy: many of the buildings they funded still stand, and the stained glass windows at St. Michael's Episcopal Church bear DeWolf names to this day.
The DeWolf family fortune was based on buying and selling human beings. For over fifty years and three generations, from 1769 to 1820, the DeWolfs were America's leading slave traders. In Traces of the Trade, Browne and other family members follow the path of the Triangle Trade as they seek to better understand this dark period of their family history. The film points out that U.S. slavery was not just a Southern industry; the North was an active participant as well. It also raises important questions related to modern-day race relations: Do descendants of slave traders have a special obligation to accept responsibility for the "living consequences of their ancestors' crimes? What can or should they do to make amends, if anything? As a nation, how do we deal with what we have all inherited from our country's history?
ACTIVITY
Ask students what they know about slavery in the United States. List responses on the board. Explain to students that while slavery in the United States is more commonly associated with southern states, the North was also actively involved.
Give each student a map handout. Have them label Rhode Island, Cuba, and the modern-day location of Ghana on Africa's west coast.
Tell students that you are going to show them two clips from a documentary made by a woman whose ancestors, the DeWolfs, were the largest slave traders in U.S. history. She and some members of her family traveled to each of these locations on the map to better understand this part of their family's past. When they visited Rhode Island, they spoke with historians and looked at family records to learn how their ancestors carried out the trade. Here is basically how it worked:
Have students draw a line from Rhode Island to Ghana to Cuba and back to Rhode Island to form a triangle. Explain that ships in Rhode Island were loaded with products like rum, which they traded in Africa for slaves. Africans were then shipped to Cuba to work on plantations or to be sold on the open market. Molasses, derived from sugar cane produced with slave labor on plantations in Cuba, was then shipped to Rhode Island to be used to make rum. Have students label their maps with what was shipped to each port (e.g., rum from Rhode Island to Africa). Tell the class that this trading pattern is referred to as the "triangle trade.
Point out that while the DeWolfs and others such as the Brown brothers were directly involved with the slave trade, others in North also supported slavery, for example, distilling rum with molasses produced on plantations with slave labor. Businesses like ship builders, insurance companies, blacksmiths, and others benefited from the slave trade by doing business with those whose wealth was generated by slavery. The practice of slavery was not just a system in place in southern states, it was the foundation of the U.S. economy at that time.
Next, explain that when the family shown in the video went to Ghana on the west coast of Africa, they visited a place where captured Africans were brought and held before being sold as slaves. Then, show students the Suggested Clip, "Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery. As students watch, ask them to imagine what it must have been like for the people brought to that place to become slaves.
Allow students to react to what they saw in the clip. Tell the class that the DeWolf family alone owned 47 ships and brought 10,000 slaves from Africa to the New World. Today, there may be as many as half a million descendants of these people.
Ask the class to think about this question: Do the descendants of those who benefited from slavery need to help repair the injustices and inequality that resulted from slavery? Then, show students Clip 2, "Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation. Focus student viewing by having them take notes on some of the proposals for making repairs shown in the video (e.g., formal apologies, engaging in dialogue, litigation, financial compensation to descendants of slaves, investment in communities). Discuss whether or not students think it is fair for the descendants of slave traders and owners to be held accountable for the actions of their ancestors.
Have students, possibly for homework, read additional information on the POV website about the debate surrounding reparations legislation around the country. Each student should then write a position paper that states and defends his or her viewpoint on the concept of reparations.
ASSESSMENT
Students can be assessed on:
Labeling their maps completely and accurately.
Participation in class discussion.
Quality of position paper, including grammar,
organization, use of arguments, etc.
EXTENSIONS & ADAPTATIONS
Read the excerpt on the POV website
from the book, Inheriting the Trade by Thomas Norman DeWolf, one of the family members in the film. Ask students what the legacy of slavery is in the United States. Have each student bring in a news article or an object that symbolizes this legacy in their minds. Break into groups for show and tell and then have a reporter from each group summarize what was discussed. Ask students whether or not white privilege still exists in the U.S. and have them defend their responses. As part of this discussion, you may also wish to read and analyze the article, "White Privilege: Swimming in Racial Preference."
Watch the film, Traces of the Trade in its entirety. How do the emotions and overall perspectives of family members change during the course of their journey? Imagine you are a member of the group and write a journal entry after visiting each place in the film.
Delve deeper into race issues with other POV films. Two Towns of Jasper documents a town's reaction to a black man's murder at the hand of white supremacists. A related lesson plan examines white privilege. Another film, Family Name, tells about a white man's search for the slaves and slave owners who lived on the plantations once owned by his family. Use it to kick-off an essay assignment about how your students' ideas about race have evolved over time.
Learn about the horrors of slaves packed aboard ships by reading the account, "Aboard a Slave Ship, 1829." See also the information and images at Africans in America. Ask students why they think Africans were transported in this way. Discuss who was dehumanized in these circumstances. Blacks? Whites? Both?
Debate whether or not businesses in the North who indirectly profited from slavery (e.g., textile mills that used cotton produced by slave labor, tradesmen who did business with slave traders, towns in which major buildings and infrastructure are built with profits from the slave trade) are just as responsible for slavery as those who engaged in the practice directly.
Have students conduct research to learn more about their family history. Review the difference between "primary and "secondary sources of information, and talk about the types of documents or artifacts that can give clues about one's ancestors. Encourage students to tap whatever research may already exist in their families and then expand it. A free source of online genealogy records, including those for African-American families, is available at familysearch.org Students can then organize their family histories into presentations or displays and share them with the class. Have students also describe what was happening in U.S. and world history at the time one or two of their ancestors were alive.
Research modern-day slavery, including how and where it takes place, who the perpetrators and victims are, and what is being done to stop it. Ask students to identify how they could help abolish the practice and invite them to participate in the effort.
RESOURCES
Religion
This feature gives a summary of arguments both for and against slave reparations.
Slave North
This website provides a state-by-state overview of slavery in the North.
Standard 4: Understands conflict,
cooperation, and interdependence among individuals, groups, and institutions.
Civics
Standard 13: Understands the character of American political and social conflict and
factors that tend to prevent or lower its intensity.
Economics
Standard 2: Understands characteristics of different economic systems, economic
institutions, and economic incentives.
Geography
Standard 11: Understands the patterns and networks of interdependence on Earth's
surface.
Language Arts
Standard 9: Uses viewing skills and
strategies to understand and interpret visual media.
U.S. History
Standard 3: Understands why the Americas attracted Europeans, why they brought enslaved
Africans to their colonies, and how Europeans struggled for control of North
America and the Carribean.
Standard 5: Understands how the values and institutions of European economic life took root in the colonies and how slavery reshaped European and African life in the Americas.
Standard
31: Understands economic, social, and cultural developments in the contemporary United States.
ABOUT THE AUTHORCari Ladd, M.Ed., is an educational writer with a background in broadcast journalism, secondary education and media development. Previously, she served as PBS Interactive's Director of Education, overseeing the development of curricular resources tied to PBS programs, the PBS TeacherSource website (now PBS Teachers), and online teacher professional development services. She has also taught in Maryland and Northern Virginia.
Background Sources:
Jay
Coughtry, The Notorious Triangle: Rhode
Island and the African Slave Trade, 1700-1807 (Philadelphia: Temple Press,
1981);
David Eltis,
Stephen D. Behrendt, David Richardson, and Herbert S. Klein, eds., The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade: A Database
on CD-ROM (Cambridge, 1999);
George Howe, Mount Hope: A New England Chronicle (New York: Viking Press, 1959);
M.A. DeWolfe
Howe, Bristol, Rhode Island: A Town Biography (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1930).
"
["post_title"]=>
string(101) "Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North: Lesson Plan: The History and Legacy of U.S. Slavery"
["post_excerpt"]=>
string(399) "This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendents of slaves."
["post_status"]=>
string(7) "publish"
["comment_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["ping_status"]=>
string(6) "closed"
["post_password"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_name"]=>
string(11) "lesson-plan"
["to_ping"]=>
string(0) ""
["pinged"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_modified"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 11:22:47"
["post_modified_gmt"]=>
string(19) "2016-07-13 15:22:47"
["post_content_filtered"]=>
string(0) ""
["post_parent"]=>
int(0)
["guid"]=>
string(56) "http://www.pbs.org/pov/index.php/2008/06/24/lesson-plan/"
["menu_order"]=>
int(0)
["post_type"]=>
string(4) "post"
["post_mime_type"]=>
string(0) ""
["comment_count"]=>
string(1) "0"
["filter"]=>
string(3) "raw"
}
["comment_count"]=>
int(0)
["current_comment"]=>
int(-1)
["found_posts"]=>
int(1)
["max_num_pages"]=>
int(0)
["max_num_comment_pages"]=>
int(0)
["is_single"]=>
bool(true)
["is_preview"]=>
bool(false)
["is_page"]=>
bool(false)
["is_archive"]=>
bool(false)
["is_date"]=>
bool(false)
["is_year"]=>
bool(false)
["is_month"]=>
bool(false)
["is_day"]=>
bool(false)
["is_time"]=>
bool(false)
["is_author"]=>
bool(false)
["is_category"]=>
bool(false)
["is_tag"]=>
bool(false)
["is_tax"]=>
bool(false)
["is_search"]=>
bool(false)
["is_feed"]=>
bool(false)
["is_comment_feed"]=>
bool(false)
["is_trackback"]=>
bool(false)
["is_home"]=>
bool(false)
["is_404"]=>
bool(false)
["is_embed"]=>
bool(false)
["is_paged"]=>
bool(false)
["is_admin"]=>
bool(false)
["is_attachment"]=>
bool(false)
["is_singular"]=>
bool(true)
["is_robots"]=>
bool(false)
["is_posts_page"]=>
bool(false)
["is_post_type_archive"]=>
bool(false)
["query_vars_hash":"WP_Query":private]=>
string(32) "b89eed544a11e3e11e9cdb55068d4992"
["query_vars_changed":"WP_Query":private]=>
bool(false)
["thumbnails_cached"]=>
bool(false)
["stopwords":"WP_Query":private]=>
NULL
["compat_fields":"WP_Query":private]=>
array(2) {
[0]=>
string(15) "query_vars_hash"
[1]=>
string(18) "query_vars_changed"
}
["compat_methods":"WP_Query":private]=>
array(2) {
[0]=>
string(16) "init_query_flags"
[1]=>
string(15) "parse_tax_query"
}
}
Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North: Lesson Plan: The History and Legacy of U.S. Slavery
This lesson plan is designed to be used with the film, Traces of the Trade: A Story from the Deep North, which shows one family's journey to come to terms with its roots as the largest slave-trading family in the history of the United States. Classrooms can use this lesson to explore the history and legacy of U.S. slavery and whether or not reparations should be made to the descendants of slaves.
POV documentaries can be recorded off-the-air and used for educational purposes for up to one year from the initial broadcast. In addition, POV offers a lending library of DVDs that you can borrow anytime during the school year — FOR FREE! Please visit our Film Library to find other films suitable for classroom use or to make this film a part of your school's permanent collection.
OBJECTIVES
By the end of this lesson, students will:
Use viewing skills and note-taking strategies to understand and interpret video clips.
Label a map to indicate the locations and commodities used in the slave trade.
Discuss the role the North played in U.S. slavery.
Develop and defend a written position on the idea of reparations for the descendants of slaves in the U.S.
GRADE LEVELS: 6-12
SUBJECTS: U.S. History, Economics, Geography, Civics, Current Events
MATERIALS NEEDED
Method (varies by school) of showing the class online video clips
Computers with access to the Internet
Map handouts showing Rhode Island, Cuba, and the west coast of Africa. You can easily make and print a map at National Geographic's MapMachine.
ESTIMATED TIME OF COMPLETION: One 50-minute class
SUGGESTED CLIPS
Clip 1: Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery (length: 4:57)
The clip begins at 27:55, just after, "At the forts we met with... The clip ends with a shot of the "door of no return at 32:52.
Clip 2: Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation (length 4:08)
The clip begins at 67:18, just after, "At this point, I decided we should dive directly into the questions of reparations.... The clip ends at 71:26, just after, "...want to do something about it.
BACKGROUND
Katrina Browne, who directed the documentary, Traces of the Trade, is a descendant of the DeWolf family of Bristol, Rhode Island. Generations of the family include a U.S. senator, state legislators, philanthropists, writers, professors, and Episcopal priests and bishops. In colonial times, the family was one of the wealthiest on the continent. Their entrepreneurship virtually built Bristol's economy: many of the buildings they funded still stand, and the stained glass windows at St. Michael's Episcopal Church bear DeWolf names to this day.
The DeWolf family fortune was based on buying and selling human beings. For over fifty years and three generations, from 1769 to 1820, the DeWolfs were America's leading slave traders. In Traces of the Trade, Browne and other family members follow the path of the Triangle Trade as they seek to better understand this dark period of their family history. The film points out that U.S. slavery was not just a Southern industry; the North was an active participant as well. It also raises important questions related to modern-day race relations: Do descendants of slave traders have a special obligation to accept responsibility for the "living consequences of their ancestors' crimes? What can or should they do to make amends, if anything? As a nation, how do we deal with what we have all inherited from our country's history?
ACTIVITY
Ask students what they know about slavery in the United States. List responses on the board. Explain to students that while slavery in the United States is more commonly associated with southern states, the North was also actively involved.
Give each student a map handout. Have them label Rhode Island, Cuba, and the modern-day location of Ghana on Africa's west coast.
Tell students that you are going to show them two clips from a documentary made by a woman whose ancestors, the DeWolfs, were the largest slave traders in U.S. history. She and some members of her family traveled to each of these locations on the map to better understand this part of their family's past. When they visited Rhode Island, they spoke with historians and looked at family records to learn how their ancestors carried out the trade. Here is basically how it worked:
Have students draw a line from Rhode Island to Ghana to Cuba and back to Rhode Island to form a triangle. Explain that ships in Rhode Island were loaded with products like rum, which they traded in Africa for slaves. Africans were then shipped to Cuba to work on plantations or to be sold on the open market. Molasses, derived from sugar cane produced with slave labor on plantations in Cuba, was then shipped to Rhode Island to be used to make rum. Have students label their maps with what was shipped to each port (e.g., rum from Rhode Island to Africa). Tell the class that this trading pattern is referred to as the "triangle trade.
Point out that while the DeWolfs and others such as the Brown brothers were directly involved with the slave trade, others in North also supported slavery, for example, distilling rum with molasses produced on plantations with slave labor. Businesses like ship builders, insurance companies, blacksmiths, and others benefited from the slave trade by doing business with those whose wealth was generated by slavery. The practice of slavery was not just a system in place in southern states, it was the foundation of the U.S. economy at that time.
Next, explain that when the family shown in the video went to Ghana on the west coast of Africa, they visited a place where captured Africans were brought and held before being sold as slaves. Then, show students the Suggested Clip, "Ghana: Process of Entering Slavery. As students watch, ask them to imagine what it must have been like for the people brought to that place to become slaves.
Allow students to react to what they saw in the clip. Tell the class that the DeWolf family alone owned 47 ships and brought 10,000 slaves from Africa to the New World. Today, there may be as many as half a million descendants of these people.
Ask the class to think about this question: Do the descendants of those who benefited from slavery need to help repair the injustices and inequality that resulted from slavery? Then, show students Clip 2, "Ideas for Reparations and Reconciliation. Focus student viewing by having them take notes on some of the proposals for making repairs shown in the video (e.g., formal apologies, engaging in dialogue, litigation, financial compensation to descendants of slaves, investment in communities). Discuss whether or not students think it is fair for the descendants of slave traders and owners to be held accountable for the actions of their ancestors.
Have students, possibly for homework, read additional information on the POV website about the debate surrounding reparations legislation around the country. Each student should then write a position paper that states and defends his or her viewpoint on the concept of reparations.
ASSESSMENT
Students can be assessed on:
Labeling their maps completely and accurately.
Participation in class discussion.
Quality of position paper, including grammar,
organization, use of arguments, etc.
EXTENSIONS & ADAPTATIONS
Read the excerpt on the POV website
from the book, Inheriting the Trade by Thomas Norman DeWolf, one of the family members in the film. Ask students what the legacy of slavery is in the United States. Have each student bring in a news article or an object that symbolizes this legacy in their minds. Break into groups for show and tell and then have a reporter from each group summarize what was discussed. Ask students whether or not white privilege still exists in the U.S. and have them defend their responses. As part of this discussion, you may also wish to read and analyze the article, "White Privilege: Swimming in Racial Preference."
Watch the film, Traces of the Trade in its entirety. How do the emotions and overall perspectives of family members change during the course of their journey? Imagine you are a member of the group and write a journal entry after visiting each place in the film.
Delve deeper into race issues with other POV films. Two Towns of Jasper documents a town's reaction to a black man's murder at the hand of white supremacists. A related lesson plan examines white privilege. Another film, Family Name, tells about a white man's search for the slaves and slave owners who lived on the plantations once owned by his family. Use it to kick-off an essay assignment about how your students' ideas about race have evolved over time.
Learn about the horrors of slaves packed aboard ships by reading the account, "Aboard a Slave Ship, 1829." See also the information and images at Africans in America. Ask students why they think Africans were transported in this way. Discuss who was dehumanized in these circumstances. Blacks? Whites? Both?
Debate whether or not businesses in the North who indirectly profited from slavery (e.g., textile mills that used cotton produced by slave labor, tradesmen who did business with slave traders, towns in which major buildings and infrastructure are built with profits from the slave trade) are just as responsible for slavery as those who engaged in the practice directly.
Have students conduct research to learn more about their family history. Review the difference between "primary and "secondary sources of information, and talk about the types of documents or artifacts that can give clues about one's ancestors. Encourage students to tap whatever research may already exist in their families and then expand it. A free source of online genealogy records, including those for African-American families, is available at familysearch.org Students can then organize their family histories into presentations or displays and share them with the class. Have students also describe what was happening in U.S. and world history at the time one or two of their ancestors were alive.
Research modern-day slavery, including how and where it takes place, who the perpetrators and victims are, and what is being done to stop it. Ask students to identify how they could help abolish the practice and invite them to participate in the effort.
RESOURCES
Religion
This feature gives a summary of arguments both for and against slave reparations.
Slave North
This website provides a state-by-state overview of slavery in the North.
Standard 4: Understands conflict,
cooperation, and interdependence among individuals, groups, and institutions.
Civics
Standard 13: Understands the character of American political and social conflict and
factors that tend to prevent or lower its intensity.
Economics
Standard 2: Understands characteristics of different economic systems, economic
institutions, and economic incentives.
Geography
Standard 11: Understands the patterns and networks of interdependence on Earth's
surface.
Language Arts
Standard 9: Uses viewing skills and
strategies to understand and interpret visual media.
U.S. History
Standard 3: Understands why the Americas attracted Europeans, why they brought enslaved
Africans to their colonies, and how Europeans struggled for control of North
America and the Carribean. Standard 5: Understands how the values and institutions of European economic life took root in the colonies and how slavery reshaped European and African life in the Americas. Standard
31: Understands economic, social, and cultural developments in the contemporary United States.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Cari Ladd, M.Ed., is an educational writer with a background in broadcast journalism, secondary education and media development. Previously, she served as PBS Interactive's Director of Education, overseeing the development of curricular resources tied to PBS programs, the PBS TeacherSource website (now PBS Teachers), and online teacher professional development services. She has also taught in Maryland and Northern Virginia.
Background Sources:
Jay
Coughtry, The Notorious Triangle: Rhode
Island and the African Slave Trade, 1700-1807 (Philadelphia: Temple Press,
1981);
David Eltis,
Stephen D. Behrendt, David Richardson, and Herbert S. Klein, eds., The Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade: A Database
on CD-ROM (Cambridge, 1999);
George Howe, Mount Hope: A New England Chronicle (New York: Viking Press, 1959);
M.A. DeWolfe
Howe, Bristol, Rhode Island: A Town Biography (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1930).